Log In | Register
Skip to main content
Topic: Solar just stopped producing power (Read 480 times) previous topic - next topic
0 Members and 2 Guests are viewing this topic.
Solar just stopped producing power
At noon today, noticed I’m not producing any power on a nice sunny day, with the battery at 92%.

Fine, maybe the SmartSolar Charger MPPT 100/50 is offline, failed?  Nope, it on, no errors, so I can look at the history.   Looked at the power generation graph and it abruptly stopped at 9:52am today.

Fine, power cycle everything.   Nope, that didn’t do anything.

All the components (charger/inverter/batteries) are online and showing no errors.

Scratching my head, what am I missing?

A loose wire?
Bad switch?
Blown fuse somewhere (LD fuses are fine)
Dave

2017 TK
Re: Solar just stopped producing power
Reply #1 –
Did an extended power cycle (30 minutes) while in the grocery store, solar is back now.

But now I have an acrid electrical smell, so something is definitely not right.
Dave

2017 TK
Re: Solar just stopped producing power
Reply #2 –
At the time power dropped, solar voltage shot up, which would indicate the panels are delivering to the controller. Is anything else drawing 12V power right now, from the batteries - i.e. what are the readings on the battery monitor? What is the current path from charger to battery? Is there a voltage difference between the two?

Steve
2004 FL
2013 Honda Fit
Re: Solar just stopped producing power
Reply #3 –
No unusual 12V power draws at all.

I am seeing historical drops in wattage corresponding to voltage spikes.  Is that normal?

At least I can rule out a fuse/breaker, as the power cycle wouldn’t resolve the solar outage.   But turning everything off for 30 minutes does suggest the outage is related to an overloaded/overheating.

Something doesn’t smell right at all, turning off the solar panels until I can figure out what’s overloaded/overheating.
Dave

2017 TK
Re: Solar just stopped producing power
Reply #4 –
Yes, once the power output drops due to no current draw, the solar output will jump to the open-circuit voltage of the panels. Normal. The subsequent drops in solar voltage could be passing clouds or the sun partially obstructed by a leafy tree, etc. What I don't know with your hookup is where the solar charge output is directed. Even if the battery BMS's had shut down accepting charge, either the batteries or the solar charge controller should supply output to power lights, etc.

Note that batteries shutting down charge acceptance at less than 100% could be misbalance between batteries or a miscalibration of the battery monitor.

Steve
2004 FL
2013 Honda Fit
Re: Solar just stopped producing power
Reply #5 –
Looking at the state of charge at 9:52am, it was approaching 100%, so the shutdown makes sense, was normal.

What was not normal is from 11am onward until I noticed at noon, the battery power was being drained and solar charging did not resume.

The drain was using the refrigerator on AC, via the inverter, something I do everyday to conserve propane since the solar will keep up with the battery drain, bouncing between 100% & 99% throughout the day.   Something kept the solar from keeping the battery charged.

Except for that hiccup, solar charging is working again, but that acrid electrical smell has me worried something is overloaded, given the smell dissipates with the solar charging turned off, that narrows down,
Dave

2017 TK
Re: Solar just stopped producing power
Reply #6 –
May have found the issue.

Opened up where AM Solar installed the batteries, inverter, and charge controller.  Definitely where the acrid electrical smell was strongest.

Looks like the controller was hung on screws on the plywood wall of the couch pedestal, causing it to fall on what looks like bus connections!!!

Frankly surprised everything didn’t short out.

Going to put back the controller where it should be, see if I can secure it a bit more.   I have driven some very VERY bouncy roads in Newfoundland.
Dave

2017 TK
Re: Solar just stopped producing power
Reply #7 –
Found the source of the acrid smell, the wires going into the controller that were on the exposed terminals.

Really surprised the controller is up and running!

Since the controller is working and there is plenty of cable, can I cut off the melted end, and reinsert?

That’s assuming the terminal isn’t damaged.

I see that two screws are now missing, which is why the controller fell.

Sloppy on AM Solar not to have plastic cover over that connection.

Dave

2017 TK
Re: Solar just stopped producing power
Reply #8 –
Scary! Good thing you smelled the problem.

I really wish Victron's products would accept ring terminals, instead of using those stupid "clamp the wire" setscrew terminals that can loosen, and are so close together that a stray strand can easily short things out.
Andy Baird
2021 Ford Ranger towing 2019 Airstream 19CB
Previously: 1985 LD Twin/King "Gertie"; 2003 LD Midbath "Skylark"
Re: Solar just stopped producing power
Reply #9 –
Yes, I would definitely clean up and reterminate those burned cable ends. Scary they have the positive and negative connections adjacent!

Steve
2004 FL
2013 Honda Fit
Re: Solar just stopped producing power
Reply #10 –
Tips for cutting such a thick cable?

And for that matter, making sure the screws don’t come loose again, sealant, epoxy or liquid nails in the screw holes?
Dave

2017 TK
Re: Solar just stopped producing power
Reply #11 –
Hi Dave; I'm glad you found that.  Sealant on the screws holding the controller onto the plywood, or some sealant on the controller so it doesn't fall off again.   No sealant or thread lock or anything else on the screws holding the stranded copper cables. Those need to be clean and uncontaminated.  The wire retaining screws are part of the connecting circuit, not just physically retaining the wire. The enlarged surface area of the threads decreases the amount of current per square mm passing through.  Using spade type ring terminals, as Andy stated, is far superior, but costs more and uses up more real estate. Victron should enlarge that area. High currents are always going to dissipate heat at a connection, and the connections should be farther apart to avoid heat build up in one small area.
   I think a small wire brush should clean up the copper involved in the connection. I would cut some of the melted and charred vinyl insulation out of the way. (don't nick or damage the conductors) I didn't see any arc marks or melted copper.  I'd use heat shrink over the copper wires to cover where any insulation is missing. but without a good heat gun, use tape. My choice of tape is 3M Super 33+ available in black and red. https://www.homedepot.com/p/Scotch-Super-33-3-4-in-x-66-ft-x-0-007-in-Vinyl-Electrical-Tape-Black-6132-BA-10/304653556  You can use any tape in a pinch, but try to avoid the bargain stuff. If all the components are secure, you don't necessarily have to have the insulation at all, but not an optimum choice if that can be avoided. Tape will do for temporary repairs. RonB
    edit: Pliers with a serrated jaw, or a file (jewelers file) can reshape copper terminals,; remove lumps of melted copper if present.  A PM step to re-tighten screws involved with tight connections should be done routinely, as with the electrical panel, circuit breaker connections.  RB
RonB (Bostick) living in San Diego
Original owner of "Bluebelle" a '99 TKB
Re: Solar just stopped producing power
Reply #12 –
Quote from: RonB  - 
A PM step to re-tighten screws involved with tight connections should be done routinely, as with the electrical panel, circuit breaker connections.

At first, the acrid electrical smell seemed to be coming from the fridge area, so I opened up the panel to check all the connections, nope, all tight.

Boondocked at Walmart, across from a Canadian Tire & Home Depot in St John’s last night, to be near tools & parts, etc if needed today.  Whoever inherits my LD will curse my periodic use of Robertson screws.

If I can’t salvage the Victron SmartSolar Charger MPPT 100/50, I’m hoping the only solar installer in St John’s has a new one, otherwise it’s going back to the dark ages (no solar) until I’m off Newfoundland.

Thanks for all the help Steve & Ron!
Dave

2017 TK
Re: Solar just stopped producing power
Reply #13 –
Quote
Tips for cutting such a thick cable?
Since you're right across from Home Depot, pick up a pair of cable cutters like the ones in the photo. They slice right through the copper strands and leave a nice clean end. Also, the yellow cable stripper is real handy for stripping large cables.

Quote
Whoever inherits my LD will curse my periodic use of Robertson screws.
I would love it. God bless the Canadian that invented the Robertson. Whenever I do any work on the LD I always replace those awful factory fasteners with Robertsons.
jor
09 27' MB
10  Suby Forester
Re: Solar just stopped producing power
Reply #14 –
Found the cable cutter, thanks!

Didn’t have a stripper.
Dave

2017 TK
Re: Solar just stopped producing power
Reply #15 –
Hi Jor;  That Canadian might have been named Robertson. I have a larger version of that same cutter, good up to double ought, Probably 0000 too, but I haven't tried that yet.
   I work on friends RV's too. First thing I do is rip out any Robertson screws and replace them with Phillips or Allen.  Sometimes Torx. (special stuff).  RonB
RonB (Bostick) living in San Diego
Original owner of "Bluebelle" a '99 TKB
Re: Solar just stopped producing power
Reply #16 –
Hi Dave; Automated controllers for solar are nice; but you can substitute in a pinch with you!  If you have 12v native panels (36 cells) hooked in parallel, you can hook them up directly to the batteries. Lithiums will absorb everything your panel can feed. It won't be very efficient, no MPPT action, but your wiring should be able to handle it temporarily. (not sure about the fuse).  Definitely watch it, don't wander away. The BMS inside the batteries should protect things also.   RonB
RonB (Bostick) living in San Diego
Original owner of "Bluebelle" a '99 TKB
Re: Solar just stopped producing power
Reply #17 –
Rewired, but scratching my head.

The gauge wire used by AM Solar is too large to fit into the MPPT slots, so they removed strands until they fit.  Had to do the same to reconnect, but not as sloppy.

I believe Victron accepts only up to 6AWG wires, and this is larger.   So even if they used a larger gauge, it’s effectively no more than 6AWG.

It’s up and running, no smell, letting it run before closing up.

BTW, the cable cutter was worth the money spent, such a clean cut.
Dave

2017 TK
Re: Solar just stopped producing power
Reply #18 –
Quote
I have a larger version of that same cutter, good up to double ought, Probably 0000 too, but I haven't tried that yet.

Actually, that cutter does 00 with ease. I have even used it on 0000 but it takes some powerful squeezin'!

Quote
First thing I do is rip out any Robertson screws
Different strokes!!!  ;D  ;D  ;D

jor
09 27' MB
10  Suby Forester
Re: Solar just stopped producing power
Reply #19 –
"God bless the Canadian that invented the Robertson."

I don't normally go about professing my ignorance but today is the 1st I've ever heard of this "Robertson" type of screw! So it's got a square head, big deal, many American screws can be had with the same style head. Is there something unique about the shank on the Robertson? What is it that makes it preferable to other brands?   ::)
Steve S.
Lazy Bones & Cedar
2004 30'IB (Island Bed)
Yesterday is History, Tomorrow is a Mystery
Live for the day!
Re: Solar just stopped producing power
Reply #20 –
Quote
What is it that makes it preferable to other brands?

Nuthin'.  :D  Robertson was just the inventor. I think now it just describes the square head not the brand.
jor
09 27' MB
10  Suby Forester
Re: Solar just stopped producing power
Reply #21 –
Would have likely been the standard screw, beating out Phillips, if the inventor didn’t get greedy with Henry Ford.

    Robertson Screw

Robertson perfected the square socket. Definitely superior to Phillips, it’s the only common screw you can find here in Canada, everything else is an expensive specialty screw.
Dave

2017 TK
Re: Solar just stopped producing power
Reply #22 –
Traveling around the world and seeing the different ways things are constructed is interesting. Robertson screws are rare in the US, instead, our alternative screw type is the star or Torx head. Star head screws are usually used in wood construction for heavy-duty connections. I have seen a few Robertson screws for structural work at Home Depot but, checking now, I do not see any at this time at our local HD.

My favorite screw type is the Truss-Head Phillips Sharp Point Screw, they have large heads and drive well with the right size impact bit and rarely cam out. Any LD I worked on in the past will have them. They hold well in wood and sheet metal and are available in several lengths. I use the sharp point type and avoid self-drilling, except in sheet metal applications.
https://www.homedepot.com/p/Drive-Straight-8-x-9-16-in-Fine-Steel-Modified-Truss-Head-Phillips-Sharp-Point-Screws-1-lb-263-Pack-50294/100123027

Larry
Larry
2003 23.5' Front Lounge, since new.  Previously 1983 22' Front Lounge.
Tow vehicles  2020 Jeep Wrangler Rubicon, 2001 Jeep Cherokee
Photo Collection: Lazy Daze
Re: Solar just stopped producing power
Reply #23 –
Quote
My favorite screw type is the Truss-Head Phillips Sharp Point Screw

I really like those too. It was only recently that I started to use them regularly. I have to say that I too really like the torx head screws. The thing I like best about the Robertsons is you can really torque them down without the bit jumping out like its prone to do on a Phillips. Anyhow, we have lots of options when it comes to fasteners, that's for sure.
jor
09 27' MB
10  Suby Forester
Re: Solar just stopped producing power
Reply #24 –
Just realized that my Kreg pocket screw jig uses Robertson screws. Never had one of the Kreg screws strip out or break in hardwood.

Larry
Larry
2003 23.5' Front Lounge, since new.  Previously 1983 22' Front Lounge.
Tow vehicles  2020 Jeep Wrangler Rubicon, 2001 Jeep Cherokee
Photo Collection: Lazy Daze